Best Pizza Peel Reviews

If you love to spend your weekend with your friends by having them at your place, you need a pizza peel to serve them a deliciously baked pizza.

Now, finding the best pizza peel isn't as fun as using it. You will have a hard time choosing one product out of so many great paddles out there.

We understand your situation and are here to help. Once you've gone through this review article of ours, that buying decision won't seem so difficult to make anymore. Want to see? Then read on.

Is Wood or Metal Pizza Peel Better?

A wooden paddle will look much beautiful than a metal one. You can use it to serve the pizza as well. But, this type of paddle needs extra maintenance. You will have to hand-wash it, be gentle during washing, and dry it perfectly afterward.

On the other hand, a metallic pizza peel will make it easy for you in terms of maintenance. But, it won't be as stylish as a wooden one. However, using a metallic paddle is very easy. For, it comes with an incredibly thin edge. So, it gets under the pizza very swiftly.

10 Best Pizza Peel Reviews

Here are the top products that we want you to check out. The paddle you are looking for should be among them. These are the finest products available in today’s market.

1. Kitchen Supply 12-Inch x 14-Inch Aluminum Pizza Peel with Wood Handle

We are starting our review with a product that anyone will like. It’s quite simple yet elegant. People who love to deal with their stuff easily will appreciate it even more. Yes, this pizza peel will let you relax and get finished with cleaning it in no time.

I loved the aluminum paddle very much. They’ve designed it brilliantly. Therefore, you will find it conducting the heat at an outrageous speed. So, if you love to keep those perfect crusts intact, this is the device for you.

Another great thing about this paddle is that it takes less time in drying. This is the benefit of using an aluminum paddle. If it was a wooden tool, you would find it to take longer in getting perfectly dry. And in terms of durability, wood can’t come close to aluminum.

Now, it’s always fun to use a lightweight pizza peel. Since it’s the aluminum that we are dealing with, you can imagine how light it would be. So, this is the best pizza peel for home use, where comfort is the priority.

They’ve chosen to go with wood for the handle of this device. Therefore, you won’t feel the heat, thanks to the wood being a great heat insulator.

Thus, you have a very comfy grip, and your hands will be perfectly protected from any mishaps. I also liked the width of this paddle, for it allows me to hold my pizza easily.

Pros

  • Aluminum construction offers minimal maintenance
  • Large size
  • Wooden handle provides comfort
  • The handle is angled for better control

Cons

  • No hole in the handle

2. Pizza Royale Ethically Sourced Premium Natural Bamboo Pizza Peel

If you want to see a gorgeous looking pizza peel, this is the one. Since we are talking about a tool that is related to one of the most delicious foods on this planet, the look is important. A beautiful device like this helps you prepare the food with much care and enjoy the work.

Now, this is a very sturdy tool when it gets to work. You just need to be a bit caring with it. This way, you can expect a bunch of benefits from this homeboy. I didn't find it to split a bit. So, it's quite durable if taken care of.

The tool is extremely popular among chefs. Even if you look at its health aspect, they've done a great job by making it resistant to any infectious agent. And who doesn't want to maintain proper hygiene while enjoying the deliciousness of a pizza?

Another worth mentioning fact about this product is that they’ve made it awesomely eco-friendly. You will also be glad to know that there won’t be any toxicity business with this paddle.

Moreover, it offers users a great deal of comfort. You've got to check out the handle it comes with to know what I mean. The handle won't conduct any heat. Therefore, you will be quite safe while using this device.

Pros

  • Very beautiful
  • Easy cleaning
  • Extremely comfy handle
  • Eco-friendly

Cons

  • Small for 14-inch pizzas

3. Heritage Acacia Wood Pizza Peel, Great for Homemade Pizza, Cheese and Charcuterie Boards - 22" x 14"

Here's a device made of the laminated strip. And it's another beauty on our list. Those designers need to be praised for such a stylish piece of work. Now, apart from its look, it provides you with extreme comfort in terms of storage. For, this is a device that you can hang from the wall.

I always look for a tapered edge on a device like this. For, I find it to be a nice little feature for dealing with pizza. It lets me manage the food better. I love the way it lets me slide my pizza off the pizza peel.

If you are worried about the durability, then be so no more. You will find the tool to be perfectly sanded. Thus, you get a very long-lasting device. Just make sure to keep the pizza cutter away from it.

Otherwise, you will be in for a disappointment. If you manage to take proper care of the board, it will serve the purpose excellently for you. And you might want to oil it from time to time.

Now, I found the size of this paddle to be perfect for both small and large pizzas. There shouldn’t be any problem in holding a considerably sized pizza on it. So, this is a good looking pizza peel with a lot of comforts to offer. You wouldn't regret buying it.

Pros

  • Stylish
  • Very smooth
  • Tapered edge
  • Surface comes crafted

Cons

  • The handle is a bit narrow toward the base

4. Ironwood Gourmet 28214 Napoli Pizza Peel, Acacia Wood

 Ironwood Gourmet 28214

Looking for a device that will be more than just a paddle? Then check out the one we are reviewing now. Once you get your hands on it, you will realize that you’ve purchased a highly versatile tool. Yes, you can do a lot of work with it other than holding the pizza. You can use it to serve the pizza as well.

They've designed it beautifully so that you can bring it in front of your guest. This isn't one of those devices that never come out of the kitchen. Amazingly, they've chosen to go with acacia wood for this product. For, the wood seems to be just perfect as a material for pizza peels.

If you want to have your tool highly hygienic, then you will be pleased with the fact that it’s resistant to infectious agents. Therefore, it’s time you enjoyed the deliciousness of the pizza while being healthy. They’ve gone to the extremes of length to provide you with a product having great health value.

That’s why we see this device to come with no artificial coating whatsoever. The only coating you will find in it is that of mineral oil. And we said that we love to find those slanted edges on our pizza peels. Since the product has this feature, there’s no reason for us not to recommend it.

Pros

  • Beautiful wood
  • Doesn’t have any coating
  • Serves a lot of purposes
  • Tapered edge

Cons

  • You have to sand it

5.  Chef Pomodoro Aluminum Metal Pizza Peel with Foldable Wood Handle

Chef Pomodoro COMINHKPR136940

Here's another awesome product that comes with versatility. I loved it for it has an incredible handle. With a handle of this sort, the comfort of using a pizza peel is going to be on another level. Especially when you are dealing with a hot thing like an oven, you must have a safety handle on hand.

I was very impressed with the way this paddle holds the pizza. But that’s not all it has in store for me. It helps me in transferring the pizza into my oven. You can use the peel to serve the pizza as well.

The length of its handle is what made me review this outstanding paddle. You won’t find a 10-inch handle much often with pizza peels out there.

Now, aluminum is always an excellent material for any type of construction. And when it comes to pizza peels, it becomes more precious. For, you want your tool to be warp-free.

Therefore, if you are going for this remarkable tool, you rest assured that you won’t have to buy another one soon. What’s more, you have the handle to be foldable. So, you can guess how convenient the storage will be.

Pros

  • Aluminum construction for durability
  • Doesn’t warp
  • Anti-fall feature
  • Folding handle

Cons

  • Not dishwasher-safe

6. Premium 22" Wooden Pizza Peel

Update International WPP-1222

If you love your things to be plain and simple, this is the device for you. It’s for the kitchens which have more of a classical look. The device will go nicely with those retro-looking accessories of a traditional kitchen. Buy this awesome piece of pizza peel for your mom and tell me if she isn’t happy with its design.

Now, apart from its elegant design, it has a solid construction. You see, premium rubberwood is known to last a lifetime. That's how durable a pizza peel you are getting.

In terms of smoothness of the surface, I doubt that there’s any smoother paddle than this one out there. And when you add that awesome finish with an ergonomically contoured handle, magic is bound to happen. Since it’s a wooden handle, you are quite safe to take it near an oven.

For, wood won’t conduct heat. It will be an awesome heat insulator instead. So, days of burning the skin are gone with this incredible handle. Now, when it comes to shape, you've got to be impressed with this device. Oblong might be an interesting choice. But boy, does it work perfectly!

Another worth mentioning feature is the tapered edge it comes with. This type of edge makes it easy for the pizza to slide off.

Pros

  • Solid construction
  • Incredibly smooth surface
  • Comfortable handle
  • Tapered edge

Cons

  • No hole for hanging

7. Frederica Trading Bamboo Wooden Pizza Peel Paddle

Frederica Trading BLZ-33021

This is another great wooden unit that we want to review. Wood is a popular choice when it comes to materials for pizza peels. For, it stays cool even when the pizza is hot. So, you can use it to take the pizza out of the oven.

Moreover, this device is quite eco-friendly. We are talking about organic bamboo over here. So, you can imagine how greatly hygienic this tool will be. What’s more, you have one of the shortest handles that you will find out there.

Now, you might be wondering, how come a short handle is good? Well, you’ve got to hold it in your hand and use the device to know why I said so.

Another great feature of this pizza peel is its tapered edge. With such edge, you will have a great time in sliding the pizza off this paddle into a plate or oven. What’s also awesome about it is that you won’t damage the peel, even if you use a pizza cutter on it.

That’s incredible since some paddles get easily damaged if you use the cutter on them. Therefore, you can expect this paddle to last a long time. Moreover, you will have it free of any toxicity. So, you can eat fresh from now on, as there’s no chemical involved in making it.

Pros

  • The handle is short for easy control
  • Can be used as a cutting board
  • Two size options
  • Very durable

Cons

  • Might splinter at times

8. Checkered Chef Pizza Peel Extra Large Pizza Paddle With Folding Handle 15 x 13inch paddle

Checkered Chef

Here’s another pizza peel that will require low maintenance. It’s great to have a device that will serve the purpose for you and won’t ask for much in return. That way, you can spend more time baking and less time taking care of it. Apart from this benefit, it will provide you with outstanding durability.

When it comes to a stainless steel pizza peel, you feel better assured that you don’t have to buy a new one soon. Another benefit in using such a tool is that you can wash it using a dishwasher. That’s why we said that it would be quite easy to maintain.

Now, we've talked about the convenience a folding handle comes with. While you are storing the device, this handle will seem like the most adorable thing about this pizza peel. The handles that are not foldable make it difficult to store the device.

Another tiny feature that I want to mention is the hole that it comes with. You can use it to hang the device. What’s more, you have the handle to come with rubber. Since rubber is a great heat insulator, you won’t feel the heat at all. Also, such a handle won’t slip out of your hands easily.

Moreover, this paddle comes with probably the thinnest of edges. So, even if it’s a very thin crust, it will remain as it is while sliding off the paddle.

Pros

  • Durable stainless steel construction
  • Folding handle
  • Thin edges
  • The rubber on the handle

Cons

  • Unappealing

9. New Star Foodservice 50295 Wooden Pizza Peel, 14 x 16 Blade, 24" Overall, Wood

New Star Foodservice 50295

Let’s go back to a wooden device again. Birchwood might be the best wood for pizza peel. And that’s what they’ve chosen to go with.

It has a lot of benefits to offer. For instance, it will be one of the strongest of materials you will ever come across. And you need such sturdiness when you are dealing with heat.

The last thing you can expect from this paddle is for it to get warped. Moreover, they’ve done a great job by making this product resistant to any microbial particles. So, in terms of health, there will be no issue with such a hygienic product.

A great thing about it is that it won’t become slippery due to the sweat. For, they’ve made it highly moisture-absorbent. I was also impressed with the size of this device. It lets you hold a considerably large pizza.

Since it’s a strong tool, there will be no problem in using a pizza cutter on it. You can be assured that the cutter won’t damage the paddle. Thus, this device can be used for a lot of applications other than holding the pizza.

Moreover, you have tapered edges on this paddle. So, if you are worried about the crust getting ruined while transferring the pizza, then you should be so no more. For, the pizza will slide off smoothly, and the crust will be as it is, thanks to these tapered edges.

Pros

  • Durable material
  • Nice size
  • Tapered edges
  • Non-slip handle

Cons

  • Needs sanding sometimes

10. Eppicotispai 2048 Birchwood Pizza Peel, 16 by 12-Inch

 Eppicotispai 2048

This is the last but not the least one we are going to review. The durability that a birchwood offers is well-recognized. So, you will be using this device for a long time without it getting damaged in any way. Also, wood will let you hold the handle without making you feel the heat of an oven.

Since it’s a simply designed device, it won’t be difficult to clean it. Manufacturers recommend that you hand wash it. So, be gentle with it during the washing, and there shouldn’t be any problem.

I found the size of this pizza peel perfect for a regular-sized pizza as well as a large one. Yes, its dimensions are truly great. You will find the pizza to be nicely accommodated on it.

When it comes to stuff related to pizza, nothing can beat an Italian production. So, you can rest assured that the product will be durable. Another worth mentioning thing about it is that it’s amazingly affordable. In this price range, you won’t find such a classy paddle.

Also, I was impressed with the thinness of its edges. It lets me have the crusts intact. So, this is a moderately sized device that you will find very easy to use. The pizza will slide off nicely from this lightweight pizza peel.

Pros

  • Very durable construction
  • Easy to clean
  • Great dimensions
  • Nicely affordable

Cons

  • Needs to be hand washed

Here’s What to Look for before Getting One

It won’t suffice to go through the reviews of the best products for making a great buying decision. You have to learn what makes a pizza peel great. So, let’s talk about some important factors to look for before making a purchase.

Material

This is the main thing to look at. Different materials come with different benefits to offer. You need to choose a material that will go with the application you have on hand. There are three types of materials in the market. These are aluminum, wood, and stainless steel.

Aluminum

Aluminum is probably the most popular option for people who want their stuff to be lightweight. We’ve talked about some aluminum-made products in our pizza peel reviews.

In terms of durability, it’s a great option. You will love an aluminum paddle for the thinness it comes with. Thin paddles mean easier sliding off for the pizza.

Stainless Steel

A stainless steel pizza peel is all about superb strength. You will find it to be the most durable. Also, it's lighter than a wooden paddle. And its thinness is quite like that of aluminum. So, this is a great option for a beginner to go for.

Wood

Here comes the most popular option as far as pizza peels go. A wooden device provides you with a beautiful design most of the time. It goes with the kitchen’s interior very perfectly. I like this material for the classical look it offers.

What’s great about this type of pizza peel is that you can use it as a serving plate for the deliciously baked pizza. This way, it makes it simpler for you and saves you the hassle of transferring the pizza to a different serving plate.

This is something you couldn't do with an aluminum or steel device. For, they do not come with such an incredible look as the wooden peels do. Now, a wooden pizza peel has its drawbacks. It asks for heavier maintenance. Most of the time, it requires hand washing.

You cannot use a wooden paddle until it gets perfectly dried. For, if there’s any moisture left on it, it will ruin the pizza. And you cannot use any detergent to wash it. If you can get past these issues, a wooden device will be a great addition to your kitchen accessories.

Edge

In our reviews, we’ve talked about tapered edges and how they make the pizza baking more fun. Now, since the metallic paddles come with comparatively thinner edges, it’s okay if they aren’t tapered.

But, when it comes to a wooden device, you should look for those tapered edges. That way, it will be easier to get the paddle under your pizza.

Handle

This is the part of the paddle that decides whether you will be comfortable using it or not. It's needless to say that the handle needs to be ergonomic. Also, if you want to stay away from the heat of the oven, you should go for a long handle.

Now, that doesn’t mean that a short handle will be less comfy to use. It has its benefits to offer too. A short handle will let you control the paddle better while sliding the pizza off. And when you have to store the device, a short handle will make it easy for you by taking less space.

You can also look for a folding handle. It will be the best option in terms of storage. Also, make sure that the handle is sturdy. And its heat insulation needs to be spot-on.

Shape

This is another important factor to consider. For, if you get your hands on an awkwardly designed tool, your pizza baking experience might turn miserable. So, you need to buy a device that will make it easy for you to hold and slide the pizza off.

You will find the products in the market come with two shapes mainly; rectangular and round. Since the pizza will seem more befitting on a round-shaped paddle, you might want to go for it.

On the other hand, if the oven provides easier access for a rectangular paddle, you can go ahead with buying a rectangular one.

Frequently Asked Questions

Here we have some of the most commonly asked queries regarding pizza peels:

1. Is it okay to use the paddle to bake the pizza?

No, you shouldn’t use a pizza peel for baking your pizza. For, it’s made to serve a different purpose. You should use it to transfer the pizza to an oven. You can also use it to serve the pizza if it's a wooden device.

But, it’s not the device for baking the pizza. For, when you will use a pizza cutter on it, you are most likely to damage the surface of the paddle.

2. Is there any additional use of a pizza peel?

Yes, you can use it to transfer bread in and out of the oven. It can be a serving plate, also if it looks good. Some people also use the paddle as their cheeseboard. However, you shouldn’t use it as your cutting board. For, the sharp blade might damage it. And if it’s a metal paddle, it will damage the blade as well.

3. What should be the size of a pizza peel?

It will depend on the size of your pizza as well as the oven. If it’s a large oven, you can go for a big pizza peel. But, if the oven is a small one, there’s no point in buying a paddle that won’t fit inside the oven.

4. Where to buy a pizza peel?

Buying the product from an online retailer can be a great option. Also, you can buy it from a shop that sells kitchen accessories.

Final Verdict

Now that you've gone through the pizza peel reviews as well as the buying guide, I guess you can make a buying decision now. It’s time you purchased that best pizza peel you have been searching for.

But, if you aren't there yet to make the decision, I would recommend the Kitchen Supply 12-Inch x 14-Inch Aluminum Pizza Peel with Wood Handle, for it is one of a kind.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: