Top 10 Best Pizza Stone Reviews

Are you at home, craving for some delicious pizza? Well then, we have good news for you. You are now able to bake the most amazing pizzas in the comfort of your own home. All you need is a pizza stone!

Pizza stones are great for baking your favorite crispy pizzas. If you prefer the ones that are soft and thick, that is okay too. Pizza stones are the way to go no matter what type of pizzas you want to make.

Now, if you are thinking of investing in a pizza stone, you want the best one. This review article here will provide you with all the information you need to buy the best pizza stone that will cater to your hungry tummy.

Without any further ado, let’s get to it!

Do Pizza Stones Work?

Short answer, yes, they do. A pizza stone is a slab of stone that can be made from different types of materials. They can be round or have a rectangular shape and are used to heat the dough.

The material these stones are made of can range from ceramic, cordierite to metals like cast iron and steel. They all have different properties and different areas they excel at.

Baking stones are the way to go if you are looking for better taste with less effort. They bake pizzas well, allowing you to choose the kind of crusts you want. Light or dark, crispy or not, pizza stones let you be the one to decide that.

Most pizza stones have a non-stick surface, which makes them super easy to clean. They are convenient in a lot of ways, especially for those who like to bake regularly. Pizza stones can be rather versatile, as they are not only useful for making pizzas, but also a lot of other food, like bread and cookies. 

They even enhance the flavors of the pizza while being more reliable and long-lasting than metal pans. Pizza stones are the right and simpler way to make the best pizzas.

10 Best Pizza Stone Reviews

A pizza stone is a must-have for all you pizza lovers out there. If you want to cook homemade pizzas or bake moist bread with better flavor, you are going to need a pizza stone. Below, you will see a list of 10 pizza stones that we think are the best.

1. Old Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone

This rectangular baking stone is one you definitely won’t regret buying. With this product and an oven at home, you are halfway done with baking an excellent pizza.

It's cooking surface is quite big. Measuring around 14 by 16 inches, this is the best pizza stone for the oven. The item weighs about 10 pounds. This is a large pizza stone that bakes many layers of delicious, crispy pizza crusts and leaves the user craving for more.

The product absorbs and then distributes the heat uniformly. And the lead-free clay material it is made of makes this stone long-lasting. The cordierite also gives this item the ability to withstand extreme heat without cracking.

Also, this pizza stone also includes a specially designed Heat Core that focuses the heat right at the center of the stone, so you are left without any sogginess in the middle. It has a thermal shock resistance, which is a great feature to have.

Along with pizzas, you can use this Old Stone Oven pizza stone to make bread, pastries, and rolls. It does a very good job of distributing heat evenly. So, even after taking your pizza out of the oven, it will stay warm for a long time. For pizzas, take the stone and preheat it to 500 degrees in the cold oven.

Always make sure the stone has cooled down completely before you go on to clean it. Just take a damp cloth and wipe the rectangular stone. After using it for some time, the product may start to discolor — no need to be concerned about that since it is harmless.  

Moreover, this pizza stone is ideal for parties and gatherings with a lot of people. It absorbs moisture well, which is the key to getting crunchy pizza crusts.

Pros

  • Long-lasting
  • Has thermal shock resistance
  • Simple to clean

Cons

  • Very likely to discolor after some time

2. Heritage Black Ceramic Pizza Stone and Pizza Cutter Wheel

This black pizza stone by Heritage is a great place to start for those dipping their toes into the world of pizza making. It even includes a free pizza cutter.

This item measures 15.8x15.8x2.5 inches and weighs 3.15 pounds. Made from ceramic, this product has a beautiful finish. To make your life easier, it does not require any seasoning before use.

If you are ever hungry, but also in a hurry, this is the tool you will want by your side. With the ability to cook twice as much faster than any other pizza stone, this product will not let you leave the house on an empty stomach.

It has a very durable construction. You will be able to use this pizza stone for a long time without it cracking. The manufacturers have made sure it stays fresh after every wash in warm, soapy water, not leaving any marks of grease or crusts behind.

However, there have been a few complaints about the product giving off a strong chemical smell. This baking stone does a great job of making the bottom part of the pizza crispy. It is said not to release any smoke, and your food stays fresh.

Being one of the best pizza stones for ovens, this tool is worth every penny. It has enough space for a large pizza that you and your friends and family can enjoy.

Pros

  • Comes with a free pizza cutter
  • Preheats at twice as much speed
  • Quite durable so won’t crack
  • Easy to clean

Cons

  • May have a strong chemical smell

3. Pizzacraft PC9899 Rectangular ThermaBond Baking and Pizza Stone for Oven or Grill

Charcoal Companion has come up with a pizza stone that is made of an all-natural Thermion material, which also is shock-resistant. It gives more options since now you can use it not only in your oven but also on your grill! The stone is super convenient to use because there is no need for seasoning before cooking.

This product offers enough cooking space, measuring 20x13.5x6.7 inches. The ThermaBond pizza stone can endure high temperatures up to 900oF. Take your frozen pizza and reheat it in the oven with this baking stone. For cleaning, hold it under hot water and let the grease and residue wash away.

Make sure not to use soaps. With this, you can bake bread, rolls, or pizzas that are evenly heated, having the perfect dark crust. You will not be able to tell the difference between these pizzas made in your kitchen with the ones from your favorite pizzeria.

Before you first use it for cooking a pizza, preheat the oven to 500oF and put the stone by itself on the bottom rack. This helps the stone get ready before you start using it.

You will notice that the pizza stone will slowly start to darken after a while. This is due to the innate characteristics of the stone. It is nothing to worry about, and it is best if you do not try to fix that.

Pros

  • Works on both on oven and grill
  • No seasoning required
  • Easy to clean
  • Completely food safe

Cons

  • Reported having an odd smell

4. Pizza Stone for Best Crispy Crust Pizza

CastElegance

This beautiful pizza stone is the only one made with Thermite. Making tasty homemade pizzas has just become a whole lot easier. This is the perfect baking stone if you want your remarkable cooking to blow your friends and family away. This round shaped stone weighs 5.66 pounds and is 14 inches round and 5/8 inches thick.    

The Thermite used can absorb a lot of moisture. That means the crust will taste better and crispier as all the moisture from the dough is taken out. It is also very good at retaining and then passing on the heat directly into the pizza, leaving you with crispy crusts.

Also, the product has a pretty sturdy construction, so you can be sure that it will last you quite a long time. Not in the mood to use the oven? That’s okay because this item works just as great on grills! You don’t even need to worry about the pizza getting burned amidst the hot flames of the grill.

Moreover, the Thermite does an excellent job of protecting your food from the heat. Since heating it does not leave any odd smell behind, you will not face any issues there. That’s not all; you even get a free recipe Ebook!

There is a guide that comes with it, containing instructions on how to use and take care of the stone. You even get a 4x5 inches scraper to make cleaning easier.

Pros

  • Extremely durable
  • Does not smell
  • Uses Thermarite which creates crispier crusts

Cons

  • The dough may sometimes stick to it

5. Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone

Emile Henry 787514

This one is a great choice if you are looking for the best pizza stone for the oven. It does not matter what type of oven you have at home; this product works great with all ovens. This pizza stone by Emile Henry has been made using their Flame technology.

You can bake pizzas and bread of high quality with this excellent pizza stone. Did we mention it even works on BBQ grills? Well, it does. Be it gas, charcoal, or a natural wood grill, you place the stone on it and start cooking.

A simple but good thing about this baking stone is that it comes with handles. It makes carrying the hot stone very easy. Especially since this particular product has been designed to be able to endure very high oven temperatures up to 900oF, you can expect it to get really hot.  

No need to worry about causing any damages to the surface; this glazed stone does an amazing job resisting scratches. You can directly cut your pizza on it without leaving any scratch marks behind. It is truly durable.

Cleaning this appliance is a piece of cake. Just use soap and water and wipe it afterward, and you are done! It is also dishwasher-safe, so it really could not be any easier.

It is the ideal pizza stone for whenever you are in the mood to have pizzas with perfect crusts, be it crispy or soft and moist. Moreover, it gives the user a chance to make some of the most mouth-watering food while having a good time.

Pros

  • Works on BBQ grills along with ovens
  • Has handles for convenience
  • Scratch-resistant
  • Can endure very high temperatures

Cons

  • Complains about the product snapping in half

6. The Ultimate Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill

Love This Kitchen LTK-PIZZA-R16

What makes a pizza perfect? Is it the one with dark, crunchy crusts? Or one that is not soggy in the middle? Well, whatever it is, you be sure that this product does it all. This beige-colored pizza stone is made from cordierite, which is a ceramic compound and weighs about 8.8 pounds. Its size is about 16 inches.

A lot of times people complain about their pizza stones breaking after a few uses, maybe you’ve been there too. That’s something you won’t need to be concerned about with this item. This ceramic stone is capable of handling high temperatures up to 1500 degrees, so it will not crack under extreme heat.

In terms of thickness, this stone measures 0.83 inches, so it is thicker than a lot of other pizza stones. This gives the product the ability to retain a greater amount of heat before transferring it onto the pizza. And this baking stone comes with a No-Spill Stopper.

What it means is that your pizza, bread, or whatever you are baking will not slide and fall off when taking it out of the oven. This is a pretty amazing feature, one you will not find in other pizza stones. So, you can go on making flavorful dishes without worrying about spillage.

Like all great pizza stones, this one comes with detailed instructions on how to use it to make your life easier. There is even an online video tutorial you can watch. If you cannot think of what to cook, you can use the eBook with 108 amazing pizza recipes.

You can use this product to make all kinds of food. Whatever you are in the mood for, be it pastries, bread, pizza, or even cookies!

Pros

  • Contains a No-Spill Stopper
  • Can withstand very high temperatures
  • Will not crack easily

Cons

  • May leave a chemical odor without proper cleaning

7. Pizza Stone for Grill and Oven

Culinary Couture 8541891715

Next on our list is the Pizza Stone by Culinary Couture. With this stone, your options are not limited by just pizzas and bread. You can make a ton of different dishes, including chicken tenders and shrimps.

Right of the bat, we noticed that this baking stone is much thicker than most other products of its kind on the market. To be precise, it is ¾ inches thick. If you love that crispy crust of a pizza, you are in for a real treat!

This product is a heavy-duty product is here for the long run. The manufacturers did a good job using some high-grade cordierite material. So you can turn the temperature up to a 1000oF, and the stone will still do just fine. You can use it all you want, but this stone still won’t break easily.

Who doesn’t love a party with a lot of great food? You can invite all your friends and family for an outdoor BBQ grill and serve them these dishes with explosive flavors. It is compatible with most grills, even the ones fueled by gas or charcoal.

With this all-around pizza stone, you can try so many of your recipes. You can even reheat frozen pizzas in the oven. This product requires careful cleaning. Otherwise, it stains somewhat easily.

It even includes a free Ebook containing 45 mouth-watering recipes that you will get as an email. Purchase this pizza stone, and all you need to do is gather your ingredients, and you will be making great pizzas in no time!

Pros

  • An all-around product
  • Ability to withstand high temperatures
  • Made with high-quality materials

Cons

  • A bit heavier than most pizza stones

8. UNICOOK Heavy Duty Ceramic Pizza Grilling Stone

Unicook

This one is a rectangular pizza stone that measures 14.9 inches by 11.8 inches. It can be used on ovens and all types of grills. This big sized product weighs around 6.5 pounds. It is made of cordierite stone that is FDA approved.

With 5/8 inches thickness, this stone distributes the heat uniformly. This makes the process more effective and boosts your cooking performance. There is no need to worry about soggy centers because it just extracts the moisture right out of the moist dough.

And with a baking stone this large, you can easily make more than just one loaf of bread at a time. It is also quite convenient for making cookies, pastries, and biscuits. 

Something to keep in mind with pizza stone is that it cannot be seasoned with grease or oil. The cleaning process is quite convenient; all you need to do is manually wash it under warm water (no soap) after it has cooled off completely.

Moreover, this stone includes a free plastic scraper that can be used for a lot of things. You can use it as a dough cutter or even use it to scrape off the remnants left behind the sticky dough.

You will have no trouble with the smell as it does not leave a chemical odor after being heated for the first time.

Pros

  • Even heat distribution; no soggy centers
  • No chemical smell

Cons

  • Requires preheating before use to eliminate stickiness

9. Weber 8836 Gourmet BBQ System Pizza Stone with carrying Rack

Weber 8836

There are days when we crave for some warm, delicious, straight out of the oven food but don’t feel like going out to the restaurant or getting takeaways. This pizza stone by Weber is perfect for those days. The stone is made of a type of ceramic compound, known as cordierite.

This particular material helps draw out the moisture from the pizza dough, leaving you with light, crispy crusts with a dry base. And this cordierite stone has a smooth surface. The material also makes it quite strong and durable. The product has a measurement of 14x14x4 inches.

Moreover, the Gourmet BBQ System Pizza Stone includes a carrying rack, making it easily portable and safe. So, you can even take this along if you go on a picnic, camping or a BBQ party. You can sprinkle some flour over the stone or use parchment paper to make sure the dough does not stick to it.

It is truly a remarkable cooking tool for the outdoor BBQ grills. You can even add smoky flavors to your pizza using a smoker. This pizza stone makes baking super fast and easy. With this, you can make your ideal pizza without breaking a sweat.

Pros

  • Smooth surface
  • Made from cordierite
  • Portable

Cons

  • Some have complained about the smell

10. Cuisinart CPS-013 Alfrescamore Pizza Grilling Stone 

Cuisinart CPS-013

Constructed with cordierite, this baking stone lets you make pizzas of many different sizes. Along with pizzas, this product allows you to bake a variety of other food, including bread, pastries, cookies, and even desserts!

This long-lasting grilling stone does not crack when faced with temperature change. Hot or cold, the stone stays strong and gives the best performance. It even does a good job resisting thermal shock.

Moreover, this round pizza stone has a diameter of 13 inches. So, it fits just fine in most grills and ovens. With a weight of just 3.5 pounds, this thing is lightweight enough for you to carry it around. It is very easy to maintain. You can wipe the used surface with a cloth if you are up for some quick cleaning.

The product is also dishwasher-safe, but you can just as easily wash it with soap and water. One drawback of this product is that there have been a few reports about it having a strong chemical odor. This can be a bit problematic.

Enjoy perfectly crispy and light crusts with this amazing product. This tool makes sure your food has been thoroughly cooked. Be it for friends and family, or just for you, this pizza stone will not let you down.

Pros

  • Can make pizzas of different sizes
  • Can endure extreme temperature change
  • Easy maintenance

Cons

  • May stink

How to Get the Perfect Pizza Stone

Now that you are aware of how useful and great pizza stones can be, there are a few things you should keep in mind before buying one. Not all pizza stones are the same, and you need to see which one is right for you.

That is why we have made this little guide to look for so that you can find the ideal pizza stone for yourself.

Size

Pizza stones come in a lot of different sizes. Depending on the measurements of your oven and grill, you should decide which size is the perfect fit. It also depends on whether you are just cooking for a few people or a large crowd. The smaller ones are enough for a movie night with a few friends.

However, the fit is for a backyard party with a lot of people, and the largest one that fits your oven will be a lot more convenient.

Shapes

Along with the number of different sizes, these tools also don’t have a fixed shape. The round shape is usually the most common shape, mostly because they are the most convenient for ovens and broilers.

There are also a few other shapes these stones take after. This includes the rectangular shape, which is also quite popular.

Materials

Materials the stone is made of can either make or break the product, literally. Many of these materials are great at handling temperature change without cracking, but others aren’t.  

The materials also play an important role in deciding the outcome of your cooking. There are various types to choose from, including ceramic, cordierite, and even metal.

Also, the ceramic ones are usually quite reasonable in terms of affordability, and they also help make excellent pizzas. Pizza stones, which are made from cordierite, are known for being durable and efficient and uniform heat distribution.

Thickness

The thickness of the stone determines how evenly the surface is being heated. The thicker the stone, the more heat, and the pressure it can endure. And the right amount of thickness also makes sure to provide you with pizzas that have perfect crusts and no soggy centers.

With all that said, it is important to remember that really thick stones can also be quite heavy. That may make it a hassle to move around with. So, look for a pizza stone that suits you when it comes to its weight and efficiency.

Price

Different pizza stones have different prices. You will come across some that are a bit expensive but give great performance along with some nice features that you may not find in cheaper ones.

However, many offer some amazing features, while still being reasonably priced. So, it depends on your requirements and how much you are willing to spend on it.

Easy Maintenance 

After you are done with cooking and then having your meal, you may not feel like spending too much extra time cleaning after the pizza stone. That is why you need a product that does not require too much of your time and energy to clean.

Top-Rated Brands on the Market

There many good brands for pizza stones on the market. Some of the top-rated ones have been mentioned below:

Weber

Weber is best known for making dome-shaped grills. They make outdoor grills with different power sources, be it gas, charcoal, or electric. However, they also make accessories to go with their grills. The pizza stones they make are quite popular.

Emile Henry

Emile Henry is the oldest out of all the brands on this list. They are very well-known for manufacturing top quality ovenware, bakeware, and also tableware products made of ceramic.

This French brand is the go-to manufacturer for their ceramic cooking and baking products.

Old Stone Oven

The journey of Old Stone Oven began about 40 years ago, and to this day, it is still going on strong. This is basically where the idea for oven pizza stones came from.

Their products are usually better than their competitors due to their unique production method, where they use a combination of lead-free clay.

Frequently Asked Questions

Here we have some of the most commonly asked queries regarding pizza stones:

1. Are our pizza stones useful?

Pizza stones can be very helpful as they let you make restaurant-quality pizzas in your cozy kitchen. They are very convenient and truly a smart choice for those who love baking.

2. What material are pizza stones made of?

The most commonly used materials are ceramic, cordierite, and steel. Ceramic stones are quite a popular choice because they do a better job absorbing moisture from the dough, leaving crispy crusts behind. They are, however, not very good at high temperatures.

This is where a steel-based stone comes in handy. These stones conduct heat well and ensure an equal distribution of heat.

3. Do pizza stones require preheating? 

Even though it mostly depends on the materials the stone is made of, it is still better to preheat it before your first use. This process gives your cooking better results as it makes sure the entire pizza has been heated well.

Ceramic stones require preheating every time you use the product. Steel pizza stones do not usually require much preheating.

4. How to prevent the pizza from sticking to the pizza stone?

This is a common problem that has a simple solution. All you need to do is, before using the pizza stone, sprinkle some flour over it.

5. How should pizza stones be cleaned?

The cleaning method can vary from one pizza stone to the other. However, they all have some general rules, like not cleaning them while they are hot. Also, make sure to let them dry off completely before using them.

Conclusion

Well, that is all you need to know for now. We hope this pizza stone review helps you decide which pizza stone is the right one for you. Before you go on to purchase one, make sure you go through our best picks and the guide on what to look for in a pizza stone.

Now then, get ready to dive into the world of pizza making!

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: