Can You Freeze Cream Pies?

Quick Answer : Can You Freeze Cream Pies?

If you are looking for a quick answer, here it is. Yes, you can freeze cream pies even though many people do not advise. Cream pie has a short shelf life in the refrigerator. But if you follow the correct procedure, there is no reason why you should not freeze cream pie and enjoy them later without compromising the taste.

So, let us learn how to freeze cream pie in different ways. Then, you can select the way you want.

How Do You Freeze Cream Pies?

Here are the different ways of freezing cream pie.

Freezing Cream Pie The Traditional Way

1. Pre-bake the pie crust and allow it to cool to room temperature. We advise using a wire rack because it allows the crust to cool uniformly throughout. We do not recommend freezing hot or warm pies because the condensation can cause the pies to become soggy.
2. As the pie cools down, you can prepare the filling if required.
3. Once the pie cools completely, wrap it in aluminum foil tightly. Please ensure no exposure to air as it can cause freezer burn and affect the freezing process.
4. Before placing the wrapped pie inside a freezer-safe ziplock bag, check the wrapping thoroughly.
5. Squeeze excess air from the bag and seal it tightly.
6. Stick the date label and place the bag inside the freezer to freeze.

Freezing Cream Pie Made In Advance – Freezing The Pie Filling

Please note that we have already frozen the pie crust here. We shall now talk about freezing the pie filling.

1. Prepare the pie filling as per the recipe.
2. Scoop the fillings into a freezer-safe ziplock bag. Please leave some space to let the filling expand during the freezing process.
3. Gently squeeze the freezer bag to remove excess air before sealing it airtight.
4. Affix the date label and push the ziplock bag inside the freezer to freeze.

Freezing Leftover Homemade Cream Pie

Please note that homemade cream pie does not have any preservatives. So, they do not have a long shelf life. Therefore, freezing them well is the best way to preserve them for extended periods.

1. Wrap the leftover homemade cream pie in aluminum foil or cling wrap tightly. Alternatively, you can also use plastic wrap. Please ensure no gaps, as moisture exposure can damage the cream pie and affect its texture and flavor.
2. On wrapping the cream pie, you can place it inside a resealable ziplock bag. You can also set it inside an airtight plastic container.
3. Remove excess air and seal the bags or the containers.
4. Note the freezing date and push the freezer bag into the freezer to freeze.

Freezing Store-Bought Cream Pie

Store-bought cream pie has preservatives that give it long shelf life. However, you can freeze store-bought cream pie to preserve it well. However, it is not advisable to freeze the store-bought cream pie in its original packaging because it does not protect it enough.

1. Remove the cream pie from the original packing and wrap it tightly with a cling film or aluminum foil. Do not expose any area of the pie to air or moisture.
2. Once you have wrapped the cream pie tightly, you can place it inside a freezer-safe resealable bag. Remove excess air and seal the bag securely.
3. We advise noting the freezer date on a sticker on the freezer bag before pushing it into the freezer to freeze.

Freezing Cream Pie Individual Slices

We have seen various ways of freezing cream pies. Slicing the cream pies into consumable portions before freezing is an excellent option as it prevents wastage. You can remove as much cream pie as possible without thawing the entire batch. We recommend slicing the pies because it is convenient for consumption later on.

1. Cut the cream pie into consumable pieces. It is better to have the ideal size that is neither too large nor small.
2. Please note that you must wrap each slice into two or even three layers of aluminum foil to prevent exposure to moisture. Therefore, slicing it into small pieces can increase your labor.
3. Place the individual wrapped cream pies in an airtight plastic container. Remove excess air before sealing the lids tight. We suggest selecting appropriately sized containers to accommodate one pie piece each.

How Long Does The Frozen Cream Pie Last Without Losing Its Taste And Flavor?

Ideally, you can freeze the cream pies for four to six months in the freezer, provided you follow the correct procedure. But, we always recommend consuming the cream pies within two months. If you freeze the store-bought pie, it is better to finish the pie before the ‘BEST BY’ date. Keeping them in the freezer for extended periods can spoil the cream pies.

How Do You Defrost The Frozen Cream Pies?

Please remove the frozen pie from the freezer and place it inside the fridge. If you have frozen the pie fillings separately, please defrost them separately. We suggest removing the aluminum foil before defrosting. The pie should thaw entirely within a few hours.

If you do not have sufficient time, you can expedite the defrosting process by immersing the sealed freezer bag in a bowl containing tap water. The pie should defrost in two hours. But, we never recommend this defrosting mode because it can damage the pie’s texture.

Then, you can bake the pie in an oven preheated to 350 degrees Fahrenheit for 40 to 50 minutes.

Leftover frozen cream pies do not need defrosting as you can consume them directly. However, if you find it a bit hard, you can keep it inside the refrigerator for a couple of hours.

Can You Refreeze Cream Pies?

We do not advise refreezing cream pies because repeated freezing can take a heavy toll on the pie’s texture and flavor. Hence, freezing the cream pie slices is ideal.

Can You Freeze Banana Cream Pie?

You can freeze banana cream pie the way described here.

Can You Freeze Coconut Cream Pie?

Coconut cream pie does not freeze well. So, it is better to refrigerate it rather than freezing it.

Can You Freeze Boston Cream Pie?

Boston cream pie has cornstarch in the custard filling. Hence, it is not advisable to freeze Boston cream pie.

Can You Freeze Cream Cheese Pie?

You can freeze cream cheese pies by wrapping them in aluminum and storing them in freezer bags inside the freezer.

Can You Freeze Oatmeal Cream Pies?

Oatmeal cream pies freeze well. You can freeze them wrapped tightly to last for three months.

Can You Freeze Sugar Cream Pie?

It is possible to freeze sugar cream pies by wrapping them tightly with aluminum foil and placing them in airtight containers in the freezer.

Can You Freeze Coconut Cream Pie With Meringue?

Coconut cream pie with meringue contains liquid fillings that can make the pie soggy during freezing. Hence, we do not recommend freezing coconut cream pie with meringue.

Final Thoughts

Opinions are generally divided when it comes to freezing cream pies. But, we have seen that freezing cream pies is possible. We have discussed the process in detail.